November 5, 2026
If you walked out to the point at South Lido Beach this fall and looked for new markers on the water, you didn't miss them. There aren't any. The Sarasota County Commission unanimously approved a 300-foot Idle Speed/No Wake zone off Ted Sperling Park in December 2025. Almost a year later, that zone exists in county code and nowhere on Big Pass.
"However, without FWC approval, it is not enforceable," Parks, Recreation and Natural Resources Director Shawn Yeager told commissioners on Sept. 22, according to Your Observer. The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission turned the request down twice. The county is now asking for a weaker designation. What has changed is how many patrol boats are out there.
The details of the fight come from where the park sits. Sarasota County staff describe Ted Sperling Park as more than 150 acres in two sections with separate entrances: Ted Sperling Nature Park and South Lido Beach. The beach section sits where the Gulf, Big Sarasota Pass, Sarasota Bay and Brushy Bayou meet, and the county memo says the converging water creates strong currents.
For that reason South Lido Beach is not a designated swimming or bathing area. The same memo notes that the bay-side waters are "very popular for motorized and non-motorized boating activities," and says the level of boat traffic, anchoring and mooring "can pose hazards to park visitors and other boaters."
Jurisdiction adds a second complication. The park is county-owned but sits inside Sarasota city limits. South Lido residents raised that point repeatedly at county meetings, and it is why the city and county have each discussed jet ski rules separately. On July 7, 2025, the City Commission unanimously directed staff to research rules for commercial jet ski use at city parks and for vessels within 300 feet of city beaches, as the Sarasota News Leader reported.
The county has now gone through three versions of the same 300-foot area. Each one asked for less than the version before it.
| Date | What happened | Where it stands |
|---|---|---|
| Oct. 21, 2025 | Commission backs a 300-foot motorboat exclusion zone | Dropped before adoption |
| Nov. 18, 2025 | Public hearing on the exclusion zone; commission backs away from it | Replaced with a speed limit |
| Dec. 16, 2025 | Ordinance 2025-043 adopts a 300-foot Idle Speed/No Wake zone | In county code, not enforceable |
| April 9, 2026 | County submits the ordinance to FWC for review | Denied May 20 |
| June 3, 2026 | Second FWC denial after the county sends video | Final on that request |
| Sept. 22, 2026 | Commission votes to seek a Slow Speed/Minimum Wake zone instead | Pending |
The ordinance adopted in December would bar any motorboat, a definition that includes personal watercraft like jet skis, from going faster than idle speed within 300 feet of the park. The county's own notice for Ordinance 2025-043 set the hearing date. County officials said from the start that adoption alone would not put the zone into effect. It needed permits from FWC, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, the U.S. Coast Guard and the Florida Department of Environmental Protection, plus regulatory signs bought and installed, WFLA reported in April.
The same ordinance also expanded enforcement of the county park chapter beyond the Sheriff's Office to any sworn, state-certified officer, and updated park closing hours to match the posted hours, according to the Sarasota News Leader. The county's facility page for the park lists hours of 6 a.m. to 10 p.m.
Florida doesn't let a county post a speed zone on state waters without approval. Under Section 327.46 of the Florida Statutes, a local boating ordinance aimed at hazards like unsafe congestion, hazardous currents or a documented risk of collision takes effect only after FWC reviews and approves it based on substantial competent evidence. FWC's waterway markers page lays out the order: the local government asks for a Local Ordinance Review, and only after approval does it apply for a permit to place markers.
The June 3 letter from Shayna Fisher, administrator of FWC's Waterway Management Unit, as the Sarasota News Leader reported, said the application "does not demonstrate the existence of physical or navigational conditions contemplated by Section 327.46" in the area next to the park. The same letter pointed to a next step:
"The evidence submitted, including citations, written warnings, and accident data, may support a finding that the area experiences unsafe levels of vessel traffic congestion, a significant risk of collision, or a threat to boating safety. Such conditions may warrant the establishment of a Slow Speed, Minimum Wake zone."
The letter rejected idle speed for the area. It said the county's citations, warnings and accident data might support a slow-speed zone, but it did not decide whether they do. That opening is why the county's next request asks for less.
On Sept. 22 the commissioners voted unanimously to pursue a Slow Speed/Minimum Wake designation over the same 300-foot area. The discussion lasted about 35 minutes and showed the tradeoff clearly.
Commissioner Tom Knight, who served three terms as county sheriff, noted that idle speed is "very easy for law enforcement. The boat's in the water; it's simply drifting." He said a minimum-wake standard "becomes subjective," that citations based on subjective judgment get "challenged a lot," and that he would not want the county buying buoys unless law enforcement believes its officers can enforce the rule. He asked Yeager to check with law enforcement agencies, though the request was not part of the motion.
Commission Chair Ron Cutsinger answered with a highway comparison. An officer can tell when a car is doing 90 on Interstate 75, he said, and the videos residents showed the board left no doubt about how fast the jet skis were going. Commissioner Mark Smith, whose district includes Lido Key and the park, told Your Observer that any slowdown would help, adding, "Unfortunately, with government, oftentimes we need a disaster before we do anything too drastic in their eyes." Behind the whole effort is a fatal collision between two personal watercraft off South Lido in June 2025.
When Cutsinger asked how FWC would likely view the new request, Yeager said he could not speak for the agency, but that it "may be amenable" to the slower designation. "No guarantees," he added. Your Observer's Sept. 27 report described the county's next move as modifying its request to FWC. Even if FWC approves, the marker permit and signs still come after that, so for now the 300-foot zone is a proposal, not a rule on the water.
So the change on the water has come through enforcement of rules already on the books. Knight said that when he visits the park, "It seems like law enforcement has really changed the behavior out there," and that he sees "a lot of Sarasota [Police Department] boats." Yeager told the board the county works with the Sheriff's Office, Sarasota Police, FWC and contracted security in the park and nearby waters, and called the daily partnership with SPD "excellent."
Recent reporting has covered enforcement at South Lido, and the county lists the park's hours:
People who prefer to be on the water with a guide can book with the operators on the county's list of permitted vendors for rentals and scheduled tours at Ted Sperling Park:
The county's facility listing for the nature park includes a kayak launch, a wash station and mangrove water trails among its amenities.
This post is general information about public boating rules, not legal advice. Boat owners and operators should confirm current requirements with FWC or local law enforcement before heading out.
At Team Dunn, we follow the South Lido story because it shapes how a day at the south end of the island actually goes, whether you're a full-time Lido Key resident or here for the season. If you'd like to talk through life near Ted Sperling Park or anywhere else on the key, Team Dunn is glad to help. Start Your Sarasota Search.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Reach out to Team Dunn for expert real estate services. Buy, sell, or rent properties with confidence. Contact us today!