November 12, 2026
At 4413 S. Tamiami Trail, the restaurant started out cooking in the parking lot. In August, the Sarasota Herald-Tribune reported that Red Chillez, an Indian-fusion operation, was serving from a food truck on the property while the former Mama G's space was renovated into its dining room. The Red Chillez website leads with the food truck's Tamiami Trail address and calls the sit-down room its "next chapter."
A kitchen that started outside its own unfinished building fits this part of Sarasota right now. Along US 41 and Siesta Drive at the edge of South Gate, small and regional owners are filling individual buildings one at a time. The 33.95-acre shopping center in the middle, The Crossings at Siesta Key, still has more of a long-range plan than a schedule. The changes neighbors will notice this season and next are happening at the edges of the corridor.
The arrivals around the mall are spread out, and each one is moving on its own schedule. Here is where each stands based on the most recent dates its owners or local business reporters have given.
| Address | Business | What's planned | Latest stated timing |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4413 S. Tamiami Trail | Red Chillez | Indian-fusion dining room in the former Mama G's space | Food truck on site; dining room "coming soon" |
| 2139 Siesta Drive | Amalfi Bakehouse | Mediterranean-inspired café built around handcrafted cookies | "Opening Fall 2026" |
| 4131 S. Tamiami Trail | Ed's Tavern | Sports bar and restaurant in the former Chili's | 2027 |
On Siesta Drive, Amalfi Bakehouse's schedule has already moved once. In May, the Business Observer reported plans for an August opening at 2139 Siesta Drive. The bakery's own website now says Fall 2026 and describes a café "centered around handcrafted cookies, refined flavors, and sun-soaked moments." Pushing a date back by a season is normal when a small business builds out a space, and it shows how these openings tend to go. A small operator sets its own pace, so dates move one storefront at a time.
At 4131 S. Tamiami Trail, the timeline is longer and the building is bigger. The Business Observer reported in August that Ed's Tavern had leased the former Chili's, a freestanding building of more than 6,000 square feet that closed in 2025, and plans to open there in 2027. Ed's Tavern has two restaurants in Lakewood Ranch and one in Parrish, so this will be its first in Sarasota County. The same report lists a menu of wings, flatbreads, burgers and entrees, with happy hour from 3 to 7 p.m. daily. The plaza around that building sold in 2025 for $8.9 million, according to the same Business Observer story.
All three businesses are moving into restaurant and storefront buildings that are already standing, and each one is on a schedule measured in months or a year.
While new tenants line up around the edges, the main mall has been losing them. The Herald-Tribune reported in March that LA Fitness at The Crossings would close April 6, 2026, and that members were told to use the LA Fitness at 4057 Cattlemen Road, about five miles east. When it opened in 2017, that club had a three-lane pool, volleyball and basketball facilities and child care. A year earlier, the Business Observer reported that the Macy's at The Crossings was on the company's 2025 closure list.
Two well-known tenants are still operating. CMX CineBistro Siesta Key 7 lists its address as 3501 S. Tamiami Trail and posts daily showtimes. Connors Steak & Seafood lists its Sarasota restaurant at The Crossings and takes reservations online.
These two also appear in the future plan. According to Your Observer, the concept drawing for the site's redevelopment kept CineBistro and Connors in place. The plan described in 2024 called for eventually tearing down the main mall building and replacing it with a mixed-use village. That leaves a clear split on the property. Tenants housed in the enclosed mall are in the part slated for eventual demolition, while the theater and the steakhouse are drawn into what comes next.
The mall needs far more than a lease to change, and its history shows how slowly that happens. The Southgate Shopping Center opened in 1957, became an enclosed mall in 1988 and gained Saks Fifth Avenue as an anchor in 1996. Saks moved to University Town Center in 2014. Benderson Development has been assembling the property for more than a decade, according to the Herald-Tribune's March report.
The amendment's numbers show how big the eventual project could be. The Herald-Tribune reported that the applicant's proposed density of 25 units per acre would allow a maximum of 848 homes. According to Your Observer, the concept puts those apartments on the eastern side of the site, with restaurants, retail, a hotel and offices. The city's Future Land Use chapter lists the 3501 S. Tamiami Trail site under amendment 23-PA-06 and requires at least 10% of the housing to be attainable for at least 30 years. Those attainable units come in steps: at least 20 of the first 400 homes, at least 50 of the first 450 and at least 85 of the first 750.
Because of those phase thresholds, the housing is designed to come in stages, which matches the timeline Your Observer reported in 2024: a buildout of 10 to 15 years. The Herald-Tribune compared the approach to the mixed-use plan for Sarasota Square Mall farther south on the Trail.
For South Gate residents, the practical takeaway is that the businesses closest to the mall's future are also the steadiest ones today. A dinner at Connors followed by a film at CineBistro Siesta Key 7 uses the two tenants written into Benderson's concept, and both still post hours and showtimes. Former LA Fitness members were sent to the Cattlemen Road location.
The newer places run on their own calendars, so checking with each business before heading out pays off. Red Chillez posts updates on the dining room through its website and Instagram, and its site notes that food truck hours may vary when the truck is booked for private events. Amalfi Bakehouse invites people to sign up for opening news on its site. The Business Observer reported a 2027 opening for Ed's Tavern.
For now, the stretch of Tamiami Trail between Siesta Drive and Bee Ridge Road is changing one building at a time, and the mall at its center has the longest wait.
If you're tracking how The Crossings and the storefronts around it will shape the blocks you call home, Team Dunn follows these South Trail projects closely and is glad to share what we're seeing whenever you want to talk it through. Start Your Sarasota Search with a conversation about the corridor at your doorstep.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Reach out to Team Dunn for expert real estate services. Buy, sell, or rent properties with confidence. Contact us today!