November 19, 2026
Stoneybrook's club has put a larger clubhouse before Sarasota County. TPC Prestancia's owner bought the sports club next door in 2025 and is rebuilding it for a 2027 opening, while also courting members from downtown. Serenoa changed owners in May 2025 and now publishes a menu of annual passes.
None of these three clubs is standing still, and each one answers to a different kind of owner. Stoneybrook's club is the community association itself. Prestancia's club belongs to a national golf company with plans that reach beyond the gate. Serenoa belongs to a golf group that bought it a year and a half ago. A buyer comparing homes in these Palmer Ranch communities is also choosing which club's next few years will be happening down the street.
At Stoneybrook, the club and the community are one organization. The Stoneybrook Golf and Country Club of Sarasota, Inc. is the community association. Its Board of Governors sets the rules for the clubhouse and restaurant, golf, tennis, the fitness center, the pool, and architectural and aesthetic changes to homes. The current rules took effect in November 2025.
Because the club and the neighborhood share one organization, the club's building plans and the community's plans are the same thing. In fall 2025, a proposal to expand Stoneybrook's clubhouse and activity center from about 20,785 to 35,300 square feet went to a Sarasota County Planning Commission hearing on October 2. The county then set a Board of County Commissioners hearing on the related ordinance for November 18, 2025. For a Stoneybrook buyer, the clubhouse is the part of the neighborhood most likely to look different in a few years, so where that project stands is worth asking about early.
Prestancia is set up differently, with the club and the homes under separate organizations. The gated community has more than 500 homes in 12 separate neighborhoods, according to the Prestancia brochure. The Villa Palmeras homeowners association, one of those 12, says club membership is optional for Prestancia owners and that social memberships are available. TPC Prestancia is a non-equity club. Its current membership classes are Charter Golf, Traditional Golf and Sport. Both golf classes include the Stadium and Players courses.
An optional club needs a reason for people to join, and since 2025 Heritage Golf Group has been building one. In July 2025, Heritage, which already ran TPC Prestancia, bought the neighboring Sports Club of Sarasota and merged the two. The Sports Club renovation includes a 30,000-square-foot clubhouse, tennis, pickleball and padel courts, fitness and recovery facilities, group fitness studios, a pool and dining. Six new pickleball courts are open, and work on the tennis courts, fitness space and social spaces is in progress. The club expects the full Sports Club to open in early to mid-2027. Separately, the Stadium Course is getting a tee-to-green overhaul that covers infrastructure, bunkers, playability and turf health.
The club is also looking for members well outside Prestancia's gates. In April 2026, Your Observer reported on a partnership between TPC Prestancia and Saravela. Buyers at that downtown condominium get a year of free Sport membership with no initiation fee or monthly dues. After that, they can stay on a monthly plan without an initiation fee, or move up to Golf by paying the difference in initiation fees. Saravela is planned as 282 condominiums on North Tamiami Trail between 4th and 5th streets, in downtown Sarasota.
For a Prestancia buyer, the facilities next door are being expanded, and the club is building its membership from a wider area. Joining is a separate decision the owner can make on their own schedule. Published initiation fees and dues aren't posted on the club's membership pages, so buyers get current figures directly from the club.
Serenoa Golf Club, at 6773 Serenoa Drive east of I-75 and south of Clark Road, sells play directly. Business Observer reported that Walden Golf Group bought the course on May 23, 2025, and brought in Pinnacle Golf Properties to manage it. At the time, the new owners said they would start with course conditions and the guest experience and hold off on major changes.
The club welcomes public play and posts its 2026 annual pass prices before sales tax. Silver is $1,850 for a single and $3,000 for a family, Gold is $3,850 single and $5,775 family, and Platinum is $5,450 single and $8,250 family. Cart fees are listed separately for three periods: January 1 to April 30, May 1 to October 31, and November 1 to December 31, 2026. Under this model, a homeowner buys a pass one year at a time and can choose a different level the next year or skip it.
Those prices and dates are general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Confirm current club costs and how they apply to your situation with the club and the right professional.
Sarasota County single-family homes sold at a median of $485,000 in September 2026, up 7.8% from September 2025, according to the Realtor Association of Sarasota and Manatee. The same September report shows a median of 91 days to sale, sellers receiving 94.3% of their original list price, and 3.7 months of supply. Active listings that month were 2,629, down 16.2% from a year earlier.
With homes taking about three months to sell and selling below their original asking prices, buyers have time to compare one listing against another in detail. Where each club is headed is one of the clearest differences between Palmer Ranch communities. At Stoneybrook, the club is the association, and it has been working on a larger clubhouse. Prestancia's club is optional for owners and will have more to offer in 2027 than it does today. Serenoa sells golf as a separate purchase with a published price, under owners who arrived in 2025. On the seller's side, a listing does best when its marketing describes the club next door as it will be over the next few years, and the current clubhouse is only part of that. For more on the area, see our Palmer Ranch neighborhood page.
Do Prestancia homeowners have to join TPC Prestancia? No. According to Villa Palmeras, one of Prestancia's 12 neighborhoods, membership is optional for Prestancia owners, and social memberships are available.
When will the renovated Sports Club fully open? TPC Prestancia expects the full Sports Club to open in early to mid-2027. Six new pickleball courts are already open, and other areas are still under construction.
How big is the Stoneybrook clubhouse proposal? The proposal would take the clubhouse and activity center from about 20,785 to 35,300 square feet. The Planning Commission hearing was October 2, 2025, and the county set the commissioners' hearing for November 18, 2025.
Is Palmer Ranch East part of the Palmer Ranch these clubs serve? No. Palmer Ranch East is a separate project by Palmer Ranch Holdings on about 2,350 acres east of the I-75 interchange at State Road 681, near Nokomis. Business Observer reported that county commissioners approved it on September 8, 2026, as a 20-year plan for 5,700 homes. Closer to the clubs, the redevelopment of Sarasota Square is moving ahead, as covered in our update on its timeline.
If the club down the street is part of how you're choosing between Palmer Ranch communities, Team Dunn would be glad to talk through Stoneybrook, Prestancia and Serenoa with you and look at Palmer Ranch homes for sale near each one. Start Your Sarasota Search with a conversation about how golf fits your plans.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Reach out to Team Dunn for expert real estate services. Buy, sell, or rent properties with confidence. Contact us today!